I hope you're having a great summer and celebrating the 250th birthday of this great nation! I've been pretty busy and apologize that I didn't get this to you earlier. There is some info in this newsletter that pertains to everyone, so it is relevant!
“So there’s nothing our office was responsible to ‘finding,’ " says Taxpayer’s Watchdog Rob Sand after Iowa City Schools released their overdue FY 2024 audit
The release of the Iowa City Community School District’s Fiscal Year 2024 audit has generated several questions about the school district’s fiscal management, oversight by its school board, and what did the State Auditor’s office know about the situation.
The audit (conducted by Bohnsack & Frommelt LLP of East Moline, IL) - submitted 15 months after it was required by state law - found a number of issues, highlighted by the fact that district employees transferred $38 million throughout different accounts without notifying nor receiving the required approval from the district’s school board. The report also noted that the district had overspent its capital and construction funds by $19.5 million during that fiscal year. It also found that the district’s activity fund - which pays for extracurricular activities - was $1 million short. Additionally, the audit reported that the district had no documentation to show how the district had spent a $500,000 federal grant.
Maybe the most shocking revelation in the report was the fact that the district had little oversight of its payroll operations. This included the fact that there was no reconciliation between the district’s human resources and payroll departments to ensure employee contracts had been properly entered into the district’s payroll system. The audit
identified five different material weaknesses, with the greatest concern over the district’s lack of internal financial controls.
The audit has generated a lot of anger in Johnson County over the management of district finances, the apparent lack of oversight from the school board and questionable leadership from Superintendent Matt Degner on down.
But Iowans raised another issue - why didn’t the State Auditor’s office notice that there were issues with the Iowa City Schools? In typical fashion, State Auditor Sand dismissively responded on Facebook late last month:
"I know you guys are from out of town like your candidate so I’ll fill you in: nearly all Iowa public schools use a private auditor and have since before my time - including Iowa City, Des Moines, and Cedar Rapids. So there’s nothing our office was responsible to ‘find’."
Many Iowans found that response less than satisfying for someone who claims to be the taxpayer’s watchdog.
These comments generated a lot of responses on Facebook, with some including screenshots of Sand’s own official website which lists the Auditor’s official responsibilities. The first line says, “The Auditor of State has responsibility for audits of counties, cities, school districts, and other governmental subdivisions.” That corresponds with Iowa Code section 11.6, which lays out the authority and duties for these audits. The section does allow all political subdivisions to use outside auditors (which Iowa City did), who must act under the direction and authority of the Auditor of State.
In Iowa Code section 11.6, there is a provision that raises questions about these audits and Sand’s office. Section 11.6 (6) requires these audits to be completed within nine months. That is a deadline that the Iowa City schools failed to meet for its FY 2023, FY 2024, and the prospective FY 2025 audits. It also gives the State Auditor the power to give extensions if certain conditions are met. It says:
An audit required by this section shall be completed within nine months following the end of the fiscal year that is subject to the audit. At the request of the governmental subdivision, the auditor of state may extend the nine-month time limitation upon a finding that the extension is necessary and not contrary to the public interest and that the failure to meet the deadline was not intentional.
Did the Iowa City Community School District submit a request to the State Auditor to allow the district to submit its audits late?
If they did submit the requests, did the State Auditor approve their request? What was the justification given for the tardiness of the reports? What was the finding of the State Auditor which is required by law to grant the extension?
With what Iowans have learned about the disfunction of the district’s management, a failure to seek an extension does not seem farfetched. But if that’s the case, why didn’t the State Auditor and his office sound the alarm due to the failure to submit the audits on time?
There have been occasions when other audits have been late and State Auditor Rob Sand has been more than happy to let everyone know they were late. In 2021, the State Auditor took Iowa State University to task when its required audit was late. He has also been quite vociferous in alerting Iowans to when the state’s official audit was not completed on time.
Why has he been so quiet about the Iowa City Community School District’s inability to complete this legally required task on time? He doesn’t seem to have a problem pointing this out when Republicans oversee the task. Does Iowa Section 11.6 (6) not apply to Democrat-led entities?
Fiscal Year 2024 Tax Revenue Beats REC Forecast
Fiscal Year 2024 came to an end with the state seeing only a slight dip in total revenue when compared to the previous year, according to the Legislative Services Agency. For the full year, the state took in $9.565 billion in net receipts. That is a decline of just 0.7 percent when compared to Fiscal Year 2023. This exceeds the estimate of the Revenue Estimating Conference, which had predicted a 2.4 percent decline in tax receipts for FY 2024 at its March meeting.
Personal income tax – With the continued implementation of the 2022 tax cut law, personal income tax was expected to decline in Fiscal Year 2024. For the year, personal income tax collections declined by $606.1 million, or 10.8% less than FY 2023. This is a slightly larger decline than what the REC had forecast in March, when they anticipated personal income tax payments to drop by 9.9 percent for the year.
Sales and use tax – Sales and use tax collections saw a slight increase in June. For the year, sales and use tax receipts grew by $233.2 million or 5.9 percent over Fiscal Year 2022. This is almost equal to the Revenue Estimating Conference’s prediction of a 6.2 percent growth for the year. The continued strength of sales and use tax payments for a fourth year reflects the solid Iowa economy.
Corporate income tax – Changes in the tax rate and filing adjustments due to the pass through entity tax has brought some fluidity to corporate income tax collections in FY 2024. The state collected $890.5 million for the year, which is $93.6 million less than FY 2023. The decline of 9.5 percent is larger than the 0.1% drop forecasted by the REC in March.
Refunds – State revenue figures would have been stronger but for a spike in tax refund payments. The total amount of refunds paid by the state through June 30 was $1.5391 billion. This is a 30.7 percent rise in refunds from the amount paid back to taxpayers in FY 2023. Some of the growth can be attributed to the pass through entity tax process, where taxpayers could pay the new tax and get previous payments of individual income tax refunded back to them.
While Iowa has reached the end of the fiscal year, the state’s books on Fiscal Year 2024 do not officially close until the end of August. During this time, revenue and refunds that should be counted as part of FY 2024 will be accounted for. This may be more than normal due to the fiscal year ending on a Sunday. Even before those potential changes are factored in, it is clear that Fiscal Year 2024 was another strong year for state revenue.
Gambling and Sports Wagering Tax Revenue Concludes Strong Fiscal Year Performance
The state experienced another strong year for gaming tax revenue from the casinos and sports wagering tax in Fiscal Year 2024. The Iowa Racing and Gaming Commission released the year-end numbers on Tuesday.
Gaming Tax – The state collected $331.0 million in Fiscal Year 2024 from taxes on casinos. This is a decline of $11.0 million from FY 2023’s receipts. Actual revenue did exceed the REC estimate for Fiscal Year 2024 by over $9 million. The REC’s last projection for gaming tax revenue came in March, when they expected the state would collect $321.8 million.
Sports Wagering Tax – The state collected $14.34 million in Fiscal Year 2024, which is an increase of $1.4 million over FY 2023. The amount of money wagered through Iowa casinos on sporting events over the past 12 months was $2.615 billion. This is $372 million more than last year’s amount. Of that total figure for the year, over $2.4 billion was wagered via apps or on the internet.
For the third straight year, the end of the fiscal year prompts a question – will state revenue from gambling stay at these elevated levels or start to decline as competition from other states grows? The REC forecast for gaming tax revenue collections to decline by $27 million in Fiscal Year 2025.
Iowa Energy Costs and Reliability
Right before the 4th of July holiday, as everyone prepared to celebrate the 250th anniversary of our nation, the New York City Mayor strongly suggests multiple times to NYC residents to turn their air conditioning up to 78 degrees amid a heat wave in the city.
"New York: It's hot out there and the power grid is working overtime to keep us cool.
Set your AC to 78 degrees, turn off lights/electronics you're not using, and unplug what you can.
Our city is doing its part too: maintaining the 78 degree rule in our buildings, dimming/turning off our lights during peak electricity demand, asking private partners to do the same, and powering down non-essential equipment.
A stable grid means the AC stays on, and lives are saved. Let's ease demand - and get through the heat - together."
Mayor Zohran Kwame Mamdani
This is not the first time a liberal leader with a no-coal energy policy has asked residents to turn up their air conditioning.
Governor Gavin Newsom sent out a message that read, "Western states are experiencing an unprecedented heat wave.
Together, we have the power to avoid power outages.
-Before 4pm pre-cool your home to 70.
-After 4pm turn your thermostate to 78 & avoid use of big appliances."
Luckily in Iowa, we have an all-of-the above energy policy, that leads to reliable electricity as well as affordable energy rates. A recent report was released that shows Iowa with by far the lowest change in electric retail rates in the country over the last 5 years.
(See chart in photos above)
The report notes that information by the minority party and media regrading “rising electric rates” is “incomplete and potentially misleading.” The report notes that a few states and regions have increased rapidly, putting upward pressure on the national average, specifically mentioning New York and California (as shown in the above chart). Not only do NYC and California have to set their AC to 78 degrees, they must pay way more to do it!
It’s important that the data discussed on electric rates reflect Iowa’s realities. Over the past 5 years, the national average retail electricity rate has increased by approximately 4 cents per kilowatt-hour. Conversely, Iowa’s average retail rate has increased by 1.2 cents per kilowatt-hour, the smallest in the nation, and well below inflation over the same period.
Iowa Rural Certified Site Initiative Showing Success
Recently, the Hugh and Maxine Loudon Business Park in Clarinda earned an Iowa Certified Site designation through the Iowa Economic Development Authority's (IEDA) Certified Site program, joining a growing number of Iowa communities offering development-ready locations that meet nationally recognized standards.
The 61-acre site, owned by the city of Clarinda, is located along the U.S. Highway 71 and Iowa Highway 2 bypass. The certification recognizes that the property has completed environmental and infrastructure assessments and other due diligence requirements, helping reduce risk and shorten timelines for prospective development projects. Located in southwest Iowa’s Page County, the Hugh and Maxine Loudon Business Park has benefited from investments in roads, water, sanitary sewer, storm sewer, and site access improvements.
Since launching in 2012, the Iowa Certified Site program has become one of the most comprehensive in the nation, evolving alongside industry and site selection standards. Site certification is a critical factor in today’s competitive site selection landscape, with certified locations attracting more than $2.3 billion in capital investment across Iowa.
Clarinda's certification was supported through the Iowa Rural Certified Site Initiative, a program created by Iowa House Republicans during the 2024 legislative session to help rural communities offset the costs of preparing industrial sites for certification and development. Clarinda was among the first communities selected to participate. The certification process is overseen by Quest Site Solutions, a nationally recognized site selection firm based in Greenville, South Carolina. This rigorous, third‑party review provides companies with confidence that certified sites have been thoroughly vetted and are ready for investment.
Comments
Submit a CommentPlease refresh the page to leave Comment.
Still seeing this message? Press Ctrl + F5 to do a "Hard Refresh".